Recent Blog Posts
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fe5d4/fe5d4eca55439453672e6472e24991fbd5d13603" alt="Tape that reads caution lead hazard Tape that reads caution lead hazard"
Recent Uptick in Public Nuisance Claim Filings Could Indicate Broader Trend
Attorneys and legal scholars in the fields of toxic torts and environmental law are taking note of the growing popularity of public nuisance claims. These experts believe that, in a climate where class action lawsuits are becoming less and less available, and public regulation of environmental issues is decreasing, public nuisance claims may become… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2b6d/e2b6db3cb63689ff5232acc179e492411a2ceea7" alt="Man holding asbestos sign Man holding asbestos sign"
Appellate Division Rejects Toxic Exposure Claim Based on Insufficient Quantification of Exposure
Yet another court has offered an interpretation of the standard created by the Court of Appeals opinion in Parker v. Mobil Oil. The First Department (Manhattan and The Bronx) of the Appellate Division vacated a jury’s award of damages in an asbestos case, finding that the plaintiff’s expert testimony did not meet the Parker… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/49851/498512ad9f61b547a8d4dad50fe74f693750f0c6" alt="Mesothelioma sign Mesothelioma sign"
Lower Court Declines to Follow Parker v. Mobil Oil in an Asbestos Case
In a recent unpublished lower court opinion, Battistoni v. Aerco International, issued by Judge Peter Moulton of New York County Supreme Court, a mesothelioma plaintiff successfully defeated a motion for summary judgment despite an absence of quantification of exposure by the plaintiff’s expert witness. The court distinguished and declined to follow Court of Appeals… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f4afe/f4afe7ffd3104ed26684f08cf5a37f08d4babe6f" alt="Danger asbestos Danger asbestos"
Court Allows Testimony from Expert That Defendants Claim is Based on “Single Fiber” Approach
A recent ruling by a Manhattan judge in the ongoing New York asbestos litigation denied a motion by defendants to bar testimony from an expert whom defendants assert will base her testimony on a “single fiber” or “any exposure” theory of causation. This decision is in contrast to a 2016 decision by another New… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1db1a/1db1aab5dbad607a8c303edc4472e873d75d7bc6" alt="Gap coverage sign Gap coverage sign"
Appellate Division Holds Pro Rata Liability Applies when there are Gaps in Coverage for a Continuous Long Term Pollution Claim Even if the Gap was Caused by the Unavailability of Insurance in the Marketplace
A recent decision before the First Department (Manhattan) of the New York Appellate Division has found that, in a case of environmental property damage occurring over the course of decades, the insured, rather than the insurer, is responsible for losses occurring during gaps in coverage even if the insured was unable to obtain insurance… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3041b/3041bc160b91a468e4954a80be349cba5a6dad70" alt="asbestos-building asbestos-building"
Federal Court Finds Three-Hour Exposure to Asbestos-Containing Product Fails to Establish Basis for Personal Injury Lawsuit
A federal court in New York’s Southern District has recently ruled that a plaintiff who could recall only a single three-hour incident of exposure to a defendant manufacturer’s product that may have contained asbestos was not sufficient to support causation of mesothelioma in a claim for damages against that manufacturer. The recently-decided case, Holzworth… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/35692/3569251927fadbf431d044983489b335082361e7" alt="contaminated-soil contaminated-soil"
Failure to Disclose Environmental Cleanup held Fraudulent in As-Is Sale
A recent case caused the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court to consider whether a seller could be sued for failing to disclose an environmental cleanup on the property at issue, even where the property was sold as-is, and the fraud claim was brought over a decade after the purchase. The case,… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54827/54827d5ce414fab4844dc45ac79a810f02bdafd8" alt="full view of manufacturing assembly line for metal factory full view of manufacturing assembly line for metal factory"
Third Parties May Have Greater Duty to Warn after Recent Case
Manufacturers have long understood that they have a duty under the law to warn customers and consumers that their products carry risk of injury or illness, if such a risk is known. Even where the risk is carried not by something the manufacturer has made, but by a component integrated into their product that… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5f89/b5f89b3bc473af8dec7a4a31205d041f037ee487" alt="Scientist working with toxiant Scientist working with toxiant"
Update to Toxic Substances Control Act Will Change How the EPA Regulates Chemicals
After forty years without an update, the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) has recently been updated by Congress. The amended laws, passed under the Frank Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act, will vastly expand the powers of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to regulate chemical production in the US. The list of… Read More »
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bb2d3/bb2d330b20173b82c25fef665552f0bf4249f2fc" alt="The aftermath of a young person falling on icy snow The aftermath of a young person falling on icy snow"
Court of Appeals Reaffirms Storm in Progress Doctrine
In a recent opinion issued by New York’s highest court, the Court of Appeals reaffirmed that property owners will not be held liable for slip-and-fall injuries that occur during a storm. The court affirmed the Appellate Division’s decision denying damages for injuries received during an ice storm in Newburgh. In Sherman v. New York… Read More »